2026 College Rankings

Top Colleges Ranked by Selectivity Index – Crossroads League

About

The selectivity index is a rating system that looks at overall acceptance rate divided by the percentage of accepted students who enroll (yield rate). It's a measurement of both the selectivity and desirability of the college or university.

Sort by:

View as:

Rank	Institution	Selectivity Index	Acceptance Rate	SAT Score	Your Est. Net Price Avg. Net Price	Median Starting Salary	Save
1	Spring Arbor University	0.4677	37.33	1,010 – 1,230	21720	45592	#1 2026 Top Colleges Ranked by Selectivity Index – Crossroads League Spring Arbor University Spring Arbor, MI Found in Spring Arbor, Spring Arbor University’s acceptance rate is 37%. Undergraduates have to pay unknown to apply. About 100% of students attending Spring Arbor University will receive grant aid from the school. The first year retention rate is 78%....Read more Selectivity Index 0.5 6.7% Acceptance Rate 37.3% SAT Score 1,010 – 1,230 Avg. Net Price $21,720 Sign in to see your Estimated Net Price Median Starting Salary $45,592
2	Mount Vernon Nazarene University	0.345	84.3	1,010 – 1,280	23293	43046	#2 2026 Top Colleges Ranked by Selectivity Index – Crossroads League Mount Vernon Nazarene University Mount Vernon, OH Based in Mount Vernon, Mount Vernon Nazarene University accepted 84% students who applied to the school in the last admissions cycle and charges $25 for undergraduate applications. About 99% of students at Mount Vernon Nazarene University currently receive institutional grant aid. The first year retention rate is 72%....Read more Selectivity Index 0.3 7.0% Acceptance Rate 84.3% SAT Score 1,010 – 1,280 Avg. Net Price $23,293 Sign in to see your Estimated Net Price Median Starting Salary $43,046
3	Huntington University	0.3108	71.15	990 – 1,200	21149	40702	#3 2026 Top Colleges Ranked by Selectivity Index – Crossroads League Huntington University Huntington, IN 97% of students at Huntington University receive grant aid and as a NAIA Division I school, there are also athletic scholarships available. Huntington opened in 1897 as Central College, having been founded by (and still affiliated with) the Church of the United Brethren in Christ. Selectivity Index 0.3 18.7% Acceptance Rate 71.2% SAT Score 990 – 1,200 Avg. Net Price $21,149 Sign in to see your Estimated Net Price Median Starting Salary $40,702
4	Bethel University	0.2725	98.68	880 – 1,180	20058	44271	#4 2026 Top Colleges Ranked by Selectivity Index – Crossroads League Bethel University Mishawaka, IN Located in Mishawaka, Bethel University’s acceptance rate is 99% and requests unknown to apply, but fee waivers may be available. Approximately 94% of students at Bethel University will receive grant aid from the school. The college’s first year retention rate is 71% and around 54% of students will graduate in four years or......Read more Selectivity Index 0.3 17.9% Acceptance Rate 98.7% SAT Score 880 – 1,180 Avg. Net Price $20,058 Sign in to see your Estimated Net Price Median Starting Salary $44,271
5	Goshen College	0.1755	84.04	880 – 1,110	17040	43218	#5 2026 Top Colleges Ranked by Selectivity Index – Crossroads League Goshen College Goshen, IN Found in Goshen, Goshen College accepted 84% students who applied to the school in the last admissions cycle. They request unknown for undergraduate applications and . Approximately 98% of attending students currently receive institutional grant aid. The first year retention rate is 80%....Read more Selectivity Index 0.2 5.3% Acceptance Rate 84.0% SAT Score 880 – 1,110 Avg. Net Price $17,040 Sign in to see your Estimated Net Price Median Starting Salary $43,218
6	Grace College and Theological Seminary	0.1685	80.78	970 – 1,190	21680	41463	#6 2026 Top Colleges Ranked by Selectivity Index – Crossroads League Grace College and Theological Seminary Winona Lake, IN Grace College and Theological Seminary was founded in 1948, though it has roots going back to 1937. Affiliated with the Charis Fellowship, the school’s motto is “To know Christ and to make Him known.” On campus, 80% of freshmen return for their sophomore year, and 72% graduate within six years. Selectivity Index 0.2 10.3% Acceptance Rate 80.8% SAT Score 970 – 1,190 Avg. Net Price $21,680 Sign in to see your Estimated Net Price Median Starting Salary $41,463

School data is from 2022–2023 (top 500 results shown) for schools with at least 100 undergraduate students.

2026 College Rankings

Top Colleges Ranked by Selectivity Index – Crossroads League

About

2026 Top Colleges Ranked by Selectivity Index – Crossroads League

Spring Arbor UniversitySpring Arbor, MI

0.5 6.7%

37.3%

1,010 – 1,230

$21,720

$45,592

2026 Top Colleges Ranked by Selectivity Index – Crossroads League

Mount Vernon Nazarene UniversityMount Vernon, OH

0.3 7.0%

84.3%

1,010 – 1,280

$23,293

$43,046

2026 Top Colleges Ranked by Selectivity Index – Crossroads League

Huntington UniversityHuntington, IN

0.3 18.7%

71.2%

990 – 1,200

$21,149

$40,702

2026 Top Colleges Ranked by Selectivity Index – Crossroads League

Bethel UniversityMishawaka, IN

0.3 17.9%

98.7%

880 – 1,180

$20,058

$44,271

2026 Top Colleges Ranked by Selectivity Index – Crossroads League

Goshen CollegeGoshen, IN

0.2 5.3%

84.0%

880 – 1,110

$17,040

$43,218

2026 Top Colleges Ranked by Selectivity Index – Crossroads League

Grace College and Theological SeminaryWinona Lake, IN

0.2 10.3%

80.8%

970 – 1,190

$21,680

$41,463

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Spring Arbor University
Spring Arbor, MI

0.5
6.7%

Mount Vernon Nazarene University
Mount Vernon, OH

0.3
7.0%

Huntington University
Huntington, IN

0.3
18.7%

Bethel University
Mishawaka, IN

0.3
17.9%

Goshen College
Goshen, IN

0.2
5.3%

Grace College and Theological Seminary
Winona Lake, IN

0.2
10.3%